Tuesday, March 9, 2010

AL WEST S15 Draft Review

Kansas City McCoys

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-
ground

Bonus

Potential

SUMMARY

1

17

Claude Branson

RF

18

HS

---

ML Starter

Slap hitting speedster. Owners either like him as a lead off type guy or avoid his type at all costs. He has great speed and contact with no power, Solid run skills and some bunt ability to get on base.

1

53

Cristian Hernandez

P

18

HS

---

ALL STAR RP

3 pitch relievers are gold and Hernandez will show us why when he makes the league, solid control and stamina along with good durability. He is also a strikeout type pitcher.

2

81

Bernard Webb

P

18

HS

$550K

4A RP

Average splits will keep him in the minors for most of his career, a desperate team will give him an audition and he may cling on for a few seasons riding the bus back and forth 3 times a season.

3

114

Neifi Lugo

P

21

COL

$425K

ML SP

3rd round gem . Lugo has good splits and control to match his stamina, above average pitches will limit his impact, but he has ML potential

4

146

Miguel Duran

P

20

JC

$350K

4A

Duran is a great 4th rounder, but an average ML'er. A mixed bag with his average splits, but does have the control and pitches to make a team take a longer look at him.

5

178

Dick Velandia

2B

21

COL

$250K

AAA

Average hitters with limited defense and no speed don't make it too far out of AAA.

SUMMARY: Good All around draft. Branson would be a good pick up if he signs, or would be a great Compensation pick for next season. Either way the McCoy's sits pretty. I think KC might secretly hope he doesn't sign to turn in a second pick next season. Even without him the draft brings in a number of good prospects to build upon.

Grade: A


Las Vegas Gamble

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-
ground

Bonus

Potential

SUMMARY

1

19

Wallace Lunsford

P

19

JC

$2,320K

ML Ace

Fireball pitcher with great splits and 3 plus pitches, he has the control and stamina that a team would lean on to anchor their staff for years to come.

2

83

C.C. O'Rourke

P

20

JC

---

4A SP

Signing issues, but who cares you doesn't want him to sign for 6M with poor splits. Don't expect him to go too far out of AAA if he did sign

3

116

Lonnie James

P

22

COL

$425K

AAA

Average splits and low control should sink his long term career aspirations in the league. He might slip in a cup of coffee, but should spend his career in AAA

4

148

Terry Baxter

P

20

JC

$350K

AAA

Inning eating minor leaguer. HE does not have the splits to be a Major League Pitcher.

5

180

Mitchell Terry

RF

18

HS

---

AA

Average hitter with speed but poor base running, don't hold on to his rookie card for long it's going to be worthless

SUMMARY: Outside of their top pick, the gamble took a number of big risks, O'Rourke should net a pick in the 2nd round next season, which might not be all bad. Look to the positive and you will see the minor league pitching ranks should be fatigue free with these good stamina and durability minor leagues joining the team.

Grade: B-

Salt Lake City Assault

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-
ground

Bonus

Potential

SUMMARY

1

4

Jack Coke

P

18

HS

$3,720K

Ml CL

Everything about Coke points to him being a superstar pitcher, except his low stamina. With his great control ,splits and pitches he should make an impact as a reliever if not an Ace closer in the league.

2

68

Clyde Martin

3B

20

JC

$550K

AAA

Powerful OF prospect who will bat .240 at his height with a ton of strikeouts, expect 25+ home runs but most likely in AAA

3

100

Alex Burch

P

19

JC

$425K

4A

Middle of the road splits does not help an otherwise decent pitcher. Don't expect him to get in the league and stay for too long.

4

133

Nelson Lankford

2B

18

HS

$350K

AAA

Speed base running and bunting are Nelson's featured game, poor batting might keep him from ever using it in a major league game

5

165

Willis Pierce

SS

20

JC

$250K

AAA

Defensive specialist, Pierce can field with the best in the league. Too bad he hits with the bottom 1% as well.

SUMMARY: Coke might have been a reach, but he is a very good player, just finding that role for him will be a challenge for a new owner. Outside of him though the rookie owner gets a whole lot of nothing in the draft to build with in the Majors. They do get a number of quality Minor League guys that will help with the minors and fatigue.

Grade: B-

Wichita Sizzlers

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-
ground

Bonus

Potential

SUMMARY

1

33

Jim Griffin

2B

18

HS

$1,000K

ML

Similar to KC's Claude Branson in that he is a slap hitting no power speedster, his batting eye isn't as good but he also comes at less of a premium and 10 picks later

1

60

Dorian Simmons

RF

18

HS

$600K

ML Bench

It's Griffin without the fielding, worse batting eye and really should platoon against right handers. But he is fast!

2

96

Quentin Morgan

P

18

HS

$550K

AAA

Poor splits on an otherwise good pitcher, he will eat a ton of Minor League innings and most likely never see a ML field in his career.

3

129

Goose Lidle

P

18

HS

---

ML Spot Starter

Well developed 18 year old who has solid splits some control and great stamina to wield his 3 pitches. He does have ML dream and should fulfill them

4

161

Rickey Pall

SS

18

HS

---

AA

Average everywhere but the boy can run, Might hope he goes the way of the college route and you get compensation in s16

5

193

Steve Erdos

LF

18

HS

---

NOT SCOUTED

SUMMARY: Wichita went to way of Speed and collected a number of fast top of the lineup guys. Griffin and Simmons though don't offer a lot else besides their smack the ball and run technique, They project either to lead the league in steals or ground into a million force outs with men on in their careers. Only time will tell

Grade: B

No comments: