Thursday, May 28, 2009

AL EAST SEASON 12 Draft review

Burlington Ice Storm

Needs from the draft: C, CF, SP

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-

Contract

Bonus

ground

SUMMARY

1

18

Iago Silva

2B

21

COL

---

---

Solid #2 guy in the lineup. He has good speed and can bunt and runs fine. He is not an overwhelming hitter, but is good enough to be an everyday guy. He is a slow learner and will need strong coaching to make is projections.

2

69

Andre Becker

RF

21

COL

---

---

Solid yet unspectacular hitter, he will provide adequate defense, he has good speed, but might struggle to maintain an everyday job in a lineup.

3

101

Bill Clinton

SS

20

JC

---

---

Clinton has always had good defense and has never had the best eye, but he got the job done, This Clinton is similar except he can't hit righties.

4

133

Joey Hartman

C

20

JC

---

---

Solid defender and pitch caller, Joey will have average offense, but should get Big League Abs in the future.

5

165

Shea Hooper

2B

20

JC

---

---

Above average speed, but he houses a below average bat. He is not going to amount to much without a DITR.

Summary: Didn't even get a whiff of a starting pitching in the 1st 5 rounds is a bit odd in this draft, but the Storm did come out of the draft with 2 solid positional players in Silva and Becker and filled a need with Hartman who should be able to climb immediately up the positional depth chart.

Grade: B-

Durham Bulls

Needs from the draft: LF/RF, SP, 1B

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-

Contract

Bonus

ground

SUMMARY

1

13

Stan Nation

SP

18

HS

MILB

$2,880K

Slightly above average splits make an otherwise solid pitcher a big reach with the 13th pick. Stan does have 4 great pitches and excellent control. Nation's stamina is also a huge question mark this high.

2

65

Hideki Chang

C

22

COL

MILB

$550K

Better suited to never take the field defensively, Chang is a power slugging DH who will struggle against a right handed pitcher. Chang is also a huge project with poor makeup and an advanced age it will be very difficult for him to make his projections without elite coaching.

3

97

Thom Costello

SP

21

COL

---

---

4A quality pitcher he has 2 good pitches and a mix of other pitches to compliment his plus control and stamina, but he has very average splits to work with on the mound.

4

129

Trace Vitiello

SP

22

COL

---

---

Vitiello lacks quality pitches to make his plus control and stamina work well for him. A better pitcher in the long run than Costello, Trace will find getting out of AAA a challenge.

5

161

Evan Sanders

RP

18

HS

---

---

Career minor League pitcher


Summary: IMO misfired on Stan Nations, but that misfire seemed to get the tone of the Bulls draft. Nation, Chang and Costello all have what could be fatal flaws for a ML career. Each should get their chances though to prove me wrong.

Grade: D


Hartford Ascension
Needs from the draft: SP, RP, BEST

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-

Contract

Bonus

Pro

ground

SUMMARY

1

3

Dick Lewis

SP

18

HS

---

---

Great velocity dominant splits and superior control, what does that spell A-C-E…? Go team this guy is the type you build around.

2

55

Walter Garcia

SP

22

COL

---

---

Garcia has good ML potential 2 plus pitches and 2 average pitches, good control and stamina and decent splits. He is a little weak around a right handed bat, but he still should get plenty of chances to prove that rating wrong.

3

87

Orber Lee

SP

22

COL

---

---

Poor splits will leave his career derailed at AAA

4

119

Sid Sanders

SP

19

JC

---

---

No pitch to lean on and poor splits might have his career halted in AA

5

151

Lucas Enders

RP

19

JC

---

---

Right hand specialists are rare in this league Enders will not break this tradition anytime soon.

Summary: Needed pitching and that they got, Lewis could be the best pure pitcher in the draft, Garcia is a nice Ml prospect and rest of these pitchers fall in line, Hartford has to be seeing the fruits of their labor as they have one of the best young farm systems coming around.

Grade: B+

Washington D.C. old school warriors

Needs from the draft: SP, RP, 2B

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

Back-

Contract

Bonus

ground

SUMMARY

1

4

Don Orosco

2B

18

HS

---

---

Probably the premier hitter in this draft. He is defensively weak at 2B, but should settle in the OF without issue. He is a perennial all-star with 40/40 capabilities. The next Casey Kaline?

1

42

Thurman Holder

SS

18

HS

---

---

Defensive prize, which has a weak bat but a decent set of wheels and good intangibles for a ballplayer. If you can hide his bat he will reward you in the field and on the bases.

2

56

Alan Shields

LF

22

COL

---

---

Slap hitting right hand hitting specialist. He has superior speed and can bunt with the best. His lack of power and his lack of left hand hitting will make him a sure platoon.

3

88

Karim Drese

CF

21

COL

---

---

UNKNOWN

4

120

Daniel Hundley

C

18

HS

---

---

UNKNOWN

5

152

Clyde Hamilton

LF

21

COL

---

---

UNKNOWN

Summary: Needed to target some pitching in this draft, but include they went after the premier hitter in the draft, Orosco. Who can blame them, Orosco is a 5 tool guy who gives the team a little of everything. Holder works fine in a ML defense and could be traded for the pitching the team needs in the future. Next year look for Washington to aim high for the pitching ranks and build that system up some.

Grade: B


No comments: