Monday, December 6, 2010

DRAFT REVIEW S18 AL EAST

Chicago Wolves

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

SUMMARY

1

29

Quentin Gibson

CF

20

Solid defender with plus power. At college he showed great speed, but did make a number of base running mistakes. He is known as a hothead and rumor is he expects to the starting CF in Chicago very soon. My scouts say otherwise.

1

52

Kelvim Kawakami

SP

20

Below average batting splits with good control. He features 2 plus pitches and 2 average pitches. He might be a solid AAA guy, t I don't see him as a ML starter

2

85

Lawrence Turner

SP

19

Average splits with no great go-to pitch. He isn't going to go far without a feature pitch or better velocity.

3

118

Carl Madson

LF

18

Below average in the field is this power right hand hitting slugger. He isn't going to play every day, but used in the right way he could be an effective ML player.

4

150

Earl Desmond

SP

20

Below average splits with one real go to pitch. He has strike out velocity, but will only be featuring that in the minors.

5

182

Erik Bristow

P

20

His forkball was legendary at Middle Georgia State. That's about all he brings to the minors.

GRADE: Got a solid defender in Gibson. He will scare a few teams away because of his low batting stats. Expect him to struggle to make the bigs and get regular at bats. The Wolves went after a number of starting pitcher options, but did not get anyone that will have ML implications

SUMMARY: C

New York Knights

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

SUMMARY

1

4

Guy Costello

SP

18

3 pitch fireballer. Costello is dominant against right handers and should be one of the top options for the Knights in the future. Only having 3 pitches is usually a sign of fault by some owners personally I would mind having Costello and his selection. His biggest knock with me is his low stamina. But expect to see him get at least 5 innings as start.

1

27

Collin Kimbrel

SP

18

4 plus pitches and pinpoint control will get him a pass to the big boys club, but his below average right handed split might cost him a few ER's over the seasons. As a late 1st rounder he's worth the risk. And should compete for a 4th or 5th rotation spot in a few seasons.

1

37

Sherry Casanova

CF

18

Average hitter with plus speed and solid defense. He's not going to change the league but should see a fair amount of time when he does arrive. I see a guy who will average 10hr and 20sb in his time.

1

44

Willie Kohlmeier

RF

18

Kohlmeier is expected to eat up left handed pitching and show above average power and work the pitchers pretty well. He doesn't provide to be much more than a 2 star prospect on any college recruiter's data sheets though.

2

61

Jesus Cela

P

18

NOT SCOUTED

3

94

Artie Lewis

RF

18

Average hitter with some speed, but he isn't talented enough to get away with only playing 1B. Might do just enough to get some time in RF and sneak into AAA.

4

126

Andy Potvin

2B

18

Shows enough power to get some interest from Ml scouts in High school, but overall the complete package isn't worth the time it took to drive to Iowa. How my scouts projected him to be a 2B is beyond me, LF at best.

5

158

Norman Sipp

SS

18

Poor man's excuse at SS, he can play in a pinch and does have some pop, but far from a ML glove or bat. Classic Minor league burn-out.

SUMMARY: 3 1st rounds last season and 4 more this season. The minors are starting to blossom with prospects or at least warm bodies. This season New York found some success in the 1st round unlike last season. 2 starting pitchers who should contribute to a successful rotation and a solid CF defender are all good catches for a team struggling with glaring holes in the minors.

GRADE: B+


Baltimore Bandits

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

SUMMARY

2

83

Quinn Tracy

3B

18

Projects to have monster power, but outside of that and a solid batting eye, Tracey is not much of a prospect. Look for him to challenge the career minor league HR record.

3

116

Don McGowan

RP

20

2 pitch solid control and durability, but really lack any ML knack for getting batters out. He will not contribute to any ML success. Period.

4

148

Keith Magnusson

SP

21

Average to below average starter who showed at Colorado State that you didn't need to throw anything better than a sloppy grapefruit to have success in the Mountain West. AA or bust.

5

180

Charlie Moseley

3B

22

High strikeout left field that had shown high power numbers in college. He isn't going to hit above .230 in his career but could do that with 30+ homers if given the opportunity

SUMMARY: for the 2nd straight year Baltimore picks without a 1st rounder. The farm is already barren one more year will not add to the fun for the future. Baltimore did pick for power and got a few minor league ball mashers, but no one that will make a dent on the ball for the big club.

GRADE: D

Durham Bulls

Round

Pick

Player

Pos

Age

SUMMARY

1

2

Joey Taft

SS

22

Better suited to play 3B. Taft has excellent contact and a solid batting eye. At Brigham Young he showed that he could knock in runs with his gap power and extra base speed. He does struggle with the base paths and will never be much more than a 15 hr guy in his career. I'm not sure Taft is a guy you can build a franchise around, but he is a nice piece to have on the team.

2

59

Morris Roberts

RF

18

Super power hitting man-child this guy has elite power potential and can already swing for the fences at 18. Watch out when he breaks into the league in 3-5 years he could be a killer. He isn't going to offer much as a defender and he shows a bit of an injury bug, but you have to be happy with him in the early 2nd round. Quite a steal!

3

92

Clint Beaulac

SP

22

Bottom of the rotation feeder, he has solid splits and control and 4 plus pitches. Great pick up in the early 3rd round. Score 2 for Durham.

4

124

Delino Park

3B

19

Average hitter without much special going on he isn't going to win you the game, but he's not going to cost you one either. He might get a cup of coffee in the majors if someone gets hurt.

5

156

Philip Gil

2B

21

The CFL just drafted their new starting QB in Gil, because he isn't playing in the MLB.


SUMMARY: Adding to their stockpile of talent. All their picks in the first 3 rounds project to be ML starters. Anytime you do that you uncork the Champaign and start to celebrate.
GRADE: A

No comments: